Fragile social states

tldr: Social states run on a promise the economy can break at any moment – centralized promises create a single point of failure and a single point of blame, so every shock tips the system into protest, crackdown or tyranny faster than a free market would.

Recently France and many European countries have been having and getting a lot of problems related to the economy consistently for quite some time. That made me think how actually fragile all your social states are.

Fragile in terms of that the external or internal conditions could degrade them first, and the blame for this also felt stronger.
I cannot claim for sure that pure capitalist states with absolute free market are fundamentally better, it is just a value judgement, but I could show you how especially socialist states are more fragile in terms of how many things in there could go wrong.

Let’s try to compare it to how it falls, where a free market – the opposite of it – would be more resilient.
The main theory here is that the free market is a fluid, fast-reacting collective consciousness, in a way, and the blow is absorbed by thousands and millions of individuals thinking about the problem, solving it individually.

The second main addition is the promise. When you don’t have any promises, you have nothing to violate. The promise is here another part of discontent, which contributes to the perception of failure.

At the same time I cannot just state that social states are just awful and they don’t work. You could cite Soviet-style socialism as something that did not work with planned economy, but we have a clear experiment how that was not working. We have now an experiment with social states in Europe which are working and were going on for more than 70 years in a way, and yet they are still fragile.
Not that the system is completely broken, it’s just very fragile that its capacity to get broken can be really fast.

Fail of the promise

The main fragile point here I see that it is the social contract that the state promises you the conditions, like benefits, in exchange for high taxes. And they promise you that because of the scale, of a centralized system, because of smarter people in the economy, they promise you that this is gonna work and that you pay huge outrageous taxes, 30-40-50%, it’s gonna make everything fine, everyone is gonna be happy, everyone gets social safety net, everyone gets benefits, disabilities and all. And everyone’s gonna work nice and live nice.

The economic conditions might change and your house of cards falls

First of all, every social state makes a plan for the current economic conditions. When conditions change, they might not be able to adapt.
Especially in Europe you’ve seen how it was consistently falling, economies slowing, stagnating and so on. But even more recent hit after they lost taxes to cheap fuel, to cheap Russian gas, that the industry started to slow and the tax income to maintain that social state. started to fall. And that is just one shock out of many.
A finance crash wipes out the tax base overnight. A pandemic leaves a spending hole you pay off for a decade. An energy transition piles green costs on industry that is already dying. AI eats another chunk of jobs, and who is left to pay those taxes then.

Today you have enough tax income to maintain it. Today your oil and gas prices are great and good and you can sustain yourself. Tomorrow it is the opposite. Another crisis comes and conditions change. Some automation comes. Conditions change again.
Half of your workforce is replaced by AI robots and who is gonna pay those taxes; when you have to make some measures for the economy which further drive away competition and nobody wants to trade with you once you start getting tyrannical.

All plans are made in good times. Even if they plan for bad times, they cannot plan for a finance crash and a pandemic and an energy shock and job automation all at once, it happens anyway. And by their nature they cannot sit and collect a big fat chest for emergencies. They can’t, because they have to spend the money – they promised you the good life. How can they sit here and let that money not work, just sitting for emergencies? Voters are gonna ask at once: what the fuck is that?

The economy is not up to them

You could say, well, yeah, but this is normal. Like we make a promise, they fail to deliver, and you demand change.
But that just does not work with the economy. The economy is not something that states have control over, that have real influence. They do to an extent try to control inflation with currency and all that, but really, this is not something up to them to decide.
They can promise you less crime, better ecology, better science or something, they can promise you that those things are under their control. If you voted for cleaner air and they clearly failed to do anything about it, even to extreme measures like shutting down industry – this is under their control very clearly, and you can demand change here. But the economy, so we can maintain the way of life, so we can maintain this promise – that is something they can’t really keep.

When the state provides everything, the demand never stops

Okay, you stayed, it was promised to you that you would be getting all this. Schools, hospitals, rich pensions and all that. But when the conditions are not being met, people protest, people are unhappy.
Even if conditions are met, who prevents people from just demanding more?
What prevents them from starting to go on the streets protesting that they just want more benefits? You promised them one, they see, we still pay a lot, why can’t we just get more? Why can’t we just demand?

Economically justified or not? Who cares? We can just demand more anyway. They promised you a shorter week, the streets demand an even shorter one. They promised you a benefit, the streets demand a bigger one. They promised you green subsidies, the streets demand the whole industry rebuilt for free.

People are disconnected from economy when you have a social state. They don’t know about how it works. They don’t participate in as much. They don’t pay for themselves out of their pocket. They don’t manage their finances enough. They rely on state. And of course they have no idea what the economy can sustain or not, what it can support or not. They have no incentive to participate and know and actually read whatever the fuck your central banks and economists are writing in their reports.

The perspective shift happens inevitably. Those who grew up in worse economic conditions and saw how a country prospers grow up believing that this is normal, that is success, and the success is not attributed to something else like oil prices or the economy cycle. They reattribute it to the politicians who were in place and just either did nothing or did not do too much damage or were actually succeeding in managing. They have no idea how to relate to this. Remember the meme, good times create weak men, blah blah? It is not about being weak. It is about growing up or coming to conscious age with expectations that might be wrong – that current conditions can continue forever, that infinite growth is possible, that quality of life cannot drop, that the state has any real insurance for anything. People who grew up already in a social state take it for granted, and I can’t blame them for that, nobody could blame anyone for expecting good times to persist. Yet that ties to the expectation that the state will provide and work perfectly.

As opposed to growing up in fair market conditions where you see yourself, you see your relatives, you are taught in school how to succeed economically, how to do business, how the economy works. A culture that does not have to be endless strife or incredible hustle, just knowing how the economy works, what real power politicians have over it – which is none – and generally the art of fending for yourself, not relying on anyone. That greatly diminishes the blame, which is the case of social states’ fragility.

And what is the natural thing for a citizen to do? Go and demand more. They can’t meet expectations, you blame them. You change these politicians, you change another. Then they tell you, oh no, we can’t. You accuse them of corruption. You accuse them of stealing, of mismanaging. And of course you would be right. You will always find the dirt of how they mismanage. Because there is no perfect resource allocator anyway. And every margin of error can be scrutinized.
Even if you consider that there is nothing more to squeeze, there is always the next set of better guys who can make it better.

It is first, the promise cannot be kept and cannot be maintained. And even if maintained, just the presence of this is an invitation to just ask for more, ask for better. Of course, there is no end to perfection. But the economy is all about compromises. And many times people will always disagree on compromises. Because you have some central party who is making decisions. And the presence of that means a lot of people are going to disagree with that.

You can’t make good peace with people here. If they demand and you agree, then you’ve just shown that it is acceptable to ask for more.
If you don’t meet the demands, then they’ll get angry at you.
The equilibrium here would be hard to reach, if at all. Different groups of the population would always want different things. The young want to not pay huge taxes. The old want to continue getting huge payments. The workforce is gonna be shrinking or expanding depending on what the current market trend is. And they are also not happy about how they see or not clearly see the result of their taxes.

Add the generation gap and you get a tug of war that never ends. On one side the young, disadvantaged, paying for a system they may never enjoy. They have little to lose, so they go to the streets, against everything, sometimes with violence. Ruining the streets is their lobby.

On the other side the beneficiaries, mostly older, who live off the current system. They have the money, the connections, the votes politicians are afraid to lose. They do not need to break windows. They lobby quietly and they get listened to, because no one dares to say no to those who hold the power.

So the state lives in a constant bipolar disorder. Everyone agrees spending should go down, yet the moment anyone tries to cut anything, both sides scream. The old want cuts, just not their own pensions and benefits. The young want better conditions but have no clear idea what to even demand, except more and cheaper and now. You cannot reduce spending and you cannot keep spending, and every attempt to move meets immediate resistance.

First comes the dependency. If you have the same government that manages everything, you have no outlet. If they do it all, then you have only one point to put pressure on. Who else are you gonna complain to? You pay them 50% of your taxes, who are you gonna ask? It is not yours, not your decision, you never make any decisions. They take everything and manage it for you, and you have zero say in anything. So how could you even create conditions where they are not constantly attacked, not constantly asked for, and at the same time able to satisfy everyone? You can’t.

They centralized it, but at the same time they centralized the single point of blame. You get this big funnel of discontent, and it all converges at the same point. And that point is not necessarily accurate, not pointing at what exactly is happening. You voted for some guys in parliament and for the economy guys to manage, both have no idea what they should do, yet the first ones get the blame for appointing the second ones, and the second ones walk free without any blame on them specifically. You are not voting for specific economy ministers after all. You are voting for those who hire them. And of course nobody checked their ability to hire the right people – competent ones who share your values, not even the politicians’ values, but the values of whoever you voted for.

And as the blame shifts, you can no longer discern who exactly is the cause. You can only blame the government in general. Whether they do good or bad, you have only the simple answer. The questions become very populist, the easy answer for everything. Screw those guys, fuck them, let’s replace them with somebody else. And when we replace them, we ask the very same question: you fucked up again, go away. Except this time those guys might not want to leave.

Tyranny one way or another

Then, there’s another dangerous concern related to that. When people successfully get their demands on economic issues, they can demand something more. And economic issues are just resource allocation, but they can demand more privileges for one group or another group. Or to do mob justice on some issue they don’t like. And quickly you get tyranny of the majority or tyranny of whoever screams the most. And the state of course would be happy to oppress whenever it’s convenient. And later expand it to oppress everywhere else.

And the opposite direction also happens. If people constantly protest for more and more economic conditions and so on, and state cannot do it, then they start to attack you back. They pass more security locations, they fund more police, they create more laws against you, they create more tools and instruments to stop this protest from happening.
Either way, you create conditions for tyranny one way or another. Hard instruments first – bans, arrests, protest zones. Then soft ones – surveillance, speech rules, frozen accounts. The toolkit here is endless.

And the POV of the politicians too. Once it is established, they have to maintain the same system, seeing how it does not work. And it discourages anyone who actually tries to fix anything – they are already put under immense pressure to perform when they have zero control over how the economy works. They can’t. So it grows apathy again, because the public understands that all of these fuckers are not gonna do anything and retorts them, which again just starts the cycle all over.

And this shift in perspective always creates the breeding ground for autocrats and their practices. I saw this firsthand in Russia, when Putin came to power under economic growth fueled entirely and solely by oil prices, and got enough public trust and indifference to continue on the path of autocracy. With the help of media control and propaganda they instilled in people the sense that they are the heralds of economic improvement, not the conditions. Same thing you see already in Europe now, when all those leftists who have been managing you for the last fifteen years turn exactly the same, all under the same idea of trust me bro, we know better. And in fact they are failing – failing both in providing you the quality of life and providing you liberty. You only get endless regression while they refuse to resign. And again it is the point of strife for the young people, who are not illusioned by their bullshit. They come to protest and see they have no support, they see the obvious, because the other generations choose to just ignore all that in the hope things will get better, or just don’t care because we already have it better, we have nothing to lose anymore.

Who comes for the promise

And what kind of people are coming to your country if it’s a social state, huh? Here we have examples already that for Europe and other similar places, immigrants come to do what? They come to live off you, they are coming for the benefits. We are not coming for work, we are not coming to make a life, we are not coming to significantly contribute to the economy – though many are – but the other part of them come in exactly because we saw how you support everything and everyone, and we are coming to profit from it.
I know about it because when I was younger I had the very same ideas.

Now consider places without social states, like America. People are coming with a clear expectation that they are getting nothing, they have barely the smallest hope to even get the papers. They know from the very start they are going to work, they know they have to do it, else they are gonna just die under a bridge. You would not expect slackers to come, you expect people who are coming with the clear knowledge that they will have to move around. And at the same time their country benefits more from it – either because a local entrepreneur got a labor force, or somebody got a worker who pays taxes. They are losing very little by inviting the workforce; they are losing only when their social state gets exploited. And if you have none of that, there is nothing to even exploit. Same filter works inside one country too – people drift from the work-heavy regions into the welfare-heavy ones. And across time – watch who comes before the benefits grow versus after.

Even if the state looks solid – for you it’s still fragile

You pay them taxes, but do you surely buy the certainty?
Here is money that you have in your hand, that you are certain you have it. The benefits are distant, questionable. Will you be able to get them? Will you have to wait in a queue to get them? Are you sure they are gonna even accept your bill? Will they even give you anything at all? You don’t know.
Even if you would be paying an insurance company, you clearly have an agreement on paper. You pay, you promise, you know the conditions beforehand. If they don’t meet the contract, you go to court.
Do you have anything like that with the state – a written agreement? Can you sue them for not fulfilling the promise? Do you even have this promise recorded anywhere? Or is it just the vibes everyone accepts?

You may look at how, for example, in Norway they have oil, they have massive funds, they promise you – but because of all that they have a lot of funds, the system is solid once and forever, they will never suffer from lack of pensions, never suffer from lack of funds and all that. And yet, how can you be sure when you have absolutely zero control over anything?

Tomorrow your group can hope for benefits. Next week a bunch of immigrants are coming and they compete for the same resources. Another day another group got hit badly economically and they are to get all of the resources.
While your local community is getting out of it, getting cuts and so on. Immigrants versus locals, young versus old, your region versus the capital – same full pot, someone always gets cut.
A wild economy still leaves someone behind – but there is no one to blame for it, not when you have no state actively managing it.

It is because it is the insurance that you did not create or set up yourself. You rely on the infrastructure which you did not enroll in by your own choice. For example, the insurance you, specifically, made a contract. It is still your choice whether to get insured at all, and how, which company, which conditions, whatever it is, whether you had any meaningful choice here, you still made it. You created such a setup, even if technically it is their infrastructure.
Whatever state provides services, you have no way to have any meaningful say except for vote every couple of years, nor you are consciously choosing the plan for you.

The golden cage rusts

That is not all. If you have part of the population constantly dissatisfied, they will protest, they will stir, they will try to organize. And you expect how any state responds to that – by getting more police, by bringing more oppression, by finding better ways to deal with rights, to deal with your crowd.
After all, you gave them the job to maintain a high standard of living. And those people who protest against what they consider an insufficient standard of living are in effect having a negative effect on keeping the same standard of living.
How should a state respond? Find a way to cut down the dissatisfied so they can pay more attention to the satisfied ones.
Of course, they would want to just stop it, find a way so there is no more protest. So the stocks are not dropping, so the credit rating is not dropping, so nobody sees and considers this country as having problems – because it’s bad for the economy, it is bad for maintaining that social state.
Yeah, with freedom of citizens, civil rights, who cares about that? They promised you the good life, whatever they call it, they will sacrifice everything to kinda keep you in the golden cage until it starts rusting.

What do you think is more likely to happen? They suddenly get to work and try to satisfy the demands, try to do something, or just crack down. What is easier and a more sure way? What is more of a guarantee? Which way lets them continue to stay in power? I think you know the answer.

Those who protest are no longer their voters anyway. They don’t need to buy loyalty from them. They already lost it. They will focus on whoever supports them right now despite the clear fuckup to deliver. That does not necessarily mean you would be in that group – because being in it means you have no right to protest against them, you have no right to get dissatisfied, you only have to eat up whatever they have and consider that a blessing.

And then the economy inevitably tanks, you are going down with them because you believed in them, in what they will provide, and they failed on that promise. And even if you did not believe, you are still screwed because you had been denied the capacity to manage your own money. You paid a huge amount of taxes, you put huge sums into that state that was supposed to provide, instead of fending for yourself, and now you are left defenseless anyway.

Comparing with an alternative

Look, I’m not trying to point out that fancy social states are completely unviable, because they have been existing for quite some time. I’m arguing how fragile they are for any substantial change.
The main comparison here relies on the lack of promises and on the eventual understanding that it is each individual’s responsibility to create better conditions for themselves. If you live in a place that makes you no promises, you have to make promises for yourself.

"Nah, you just hate leftists, you just hate socialism!" Well, yes I do. I do hate them. But I do not hate the idea of good quality of life, and everyone just attributes it to them only, as if you have either their way or bloodthirsty capitalism and no other way. The same quality of life guaranteed not by the state, not by somebody making decisions, not by somebody redistributing, but when you have healthy competition, when you have good anti-monopoly measures, when everything is truly cheap as a result of pure competition and not because somebody decided that it should be cheap. If anything, they already show how it is failing. While many would argue it is failing everywhere, in a social state it is more prominent, because you have only a single point of failure and blame for everything, which is easy to understand and attribute.

Market gives no guarantees, but risks are yours to manage. That is more than just endlessly preparing for some invisible risk – it is understanding that nothing is certain, there is no one to save you, and you are to blame for lack of preparation, for lack of thinking at all. You’ll say, well, such a system is horrible, when we have to live in endless strife. What I say, no, it’s not. It is just a way of thinking that, when adopted by everyone, makes everything stronger, like collective immunity, collective immunity for bullshit.

You say it would decrease happiness or something, but I say the opposite. It will increase happiness, knowing that you always have to stay prepared and have a lot of instruments that you built yourself, therefore you control yourself, therefore you know it can save you, and you know you can get it again. Once everyone walks the path of building resistance for themselves, they become resistant overall.

I want everyone to prosper, but I don’t want anyone to prosper under tyranny of states. I want you to have it all, I want you to possess, to own, to have capital, to have control over your life, over your assets, how you live, where you live, and how you decide to do with yourself, not them. I want you to live a long and happy life and be independent of such single points of failure.
Or rather – single points of idiocy, single points of bad decisions by centralized idiots.